Someone may choose to quit a good job because their spouse got a promotion in a new city. A couple may decide one of them should stay home to raise the children. Someone else may forego pursuing a degree to support their spouse as they earn theirs. These are all choices that make sense as long as the couple stays together.
Then comes the divorce. And suddenly, one spouse is faced with a reality they had not prepared for—providing for themselves on their own. It can be challenging to transition back to the workforce and in some cases, it may not even be possible. That’s where spousal maintenance may come in.
On the other side of the equation, being forced to pay spousal maintenance can feel like a one-two punch. Not only are they getting divorced, but now they must pay their spouse, even though their spouse is already getting a lot of the benefits and financial assets based on the overall division of property. It can feel unfair, and they think a long-term award of spousal maintenance—or any award for that matter—is too much.
The law permits spousal maintenance (or alimony as it’s called in other states) for several reasons—to help maintain the lifestyle the parties enjoyed during the marriage, to reward one spouse for the role they played in the other spouse fulfilling career ambitions, but the reason that is most likely to be reflected in a spousal maintenance order is to transition the receiving spouse to becoming self-sufficient.
Arizona law attempts to balance these interests. The state legislature has built numerous considerations into the spousal maintenance laws, and it makes for a very complex, gray area of the law.
Other than child custody, spousal maintenance is the most-litigated issue in a divorce. Spousal maintenance is also not automatic, and it is an extremely complex issue. Unlike child support, there is no formula to support an award of spousal maintenance. So, if spousal maintenance is on the table and you are fighting for or against it, you want your argument to be very, very clear. If you think your divorce is one in which spousal maintenance may be an issue, we urge you to consult with one of our attorneys.
For spousal maintenance to be an issue, one of the spouses needs to request it in either the Petition or the Response to the Petition. If neither party requests it in one of those documents, it cannot be ordered.
The Affidavit of Financial Information (AFI) is a document that both parties need to fill out when spousal maintenance is at issue. It becomes a critical document in a spousal maintenance case where the focus is often on what the receiving spouse to needs to meet their reasonable needs and whether the other spouse can afford to pay spousal maintenance and meet their reasonable needs.
The other components of spousal maintenance include what the potential receiving spouse will be receiving in property from the divorce, what their earning capacity is in the market, whether they’ve reduced their opportunities for the benefit of the other spouse. On the other side, the Court will be interested in whether the potential paying spouse can afford to pay spousal maintenance. Discovery and disclosure help the parties get the information they need to make a risk assessment and determine whether they want to settle or go to trial.
In situations where a spouse has not worked for a while or has just started working, there is often a debate over what that spouse’s earning potential might be, which is a very critical question in spousal maintenance. A vocational evaluation is a meeting with an expert who is trained in determining what someone’s earning capacity is in the market. It is commonly ordered in these situations.
Because spousal maintenance is such a gray area, both sides bear substantial risk should a spousal maintenance case go to trial. For that reason, it is often advisable to try mediation once all the relevant information has been exchanged. The purpose of mediation is to see if the parties can reach an agreement that works for both. Additionally, the parties can agree to make spousal maintenance non-modifiable; the Court on its own cannot order that.
If the parties cannot reach an agreement on spousal maintenance, the court must decide. The court can only decide after a trial.
Our award-winning team of professionals deliver the outcomes our clients need.
We offer in-person, video, and phone consultations.
We’re conveniently located in North Scottsdale, just off the 101 and Raintree.
Call us today to speak with one of our family law attorneys.
If you prefer to email, we’re always available. You can email us directly or fill out the contact form.